Research Writing and Source Evaluation
Grade 11 · English · Study Guide
Build the skills to find, evaluate, and synthesize credible sources into well-documented research essays.
Research writing is the foundation of academic work at every level — and the skills you develop in 11th grade will carry you through college and beyond. Effective research begins not with Google but with a question: What do you actually want to know? A focused, arguable research question guides your search and helps you determine which sources are relevant. Without a clear question, research becomes an undirected collection of facts.
Evaluating sources critically is perhaps the most important research skill in the digital age. The CRAAP test (Currency, Relevance, Authority, Accuracy, Purpose) gives you a framework for assessing any source — from peer-reviewed academic articles to websites to primary documents. Peer-reviewed scholarly sources, primary sources (original documents, data, first-hand accounts), and reputable secondary sources (quality journalism, textbooks) each have their appropriate uses. Not all sources are equal, and your credibility as a writer depends on choosing wisely.
Synthesis — the ability to bring multiple sources into conversation with each other and with your own argument — is what separates genuine research writing from summary. Citation is not just an academic formality; it is intellectual honesty, acknowledging whose ideas you are building on. Whether you use MLA, APA, or Chicago style, consistent and accurate citation is non-negotiable in academic writing.
| Criterion | What to Ask |
|---|---|
| Currency | When was it published? Is the information still current? |
| Relevance | Does it directly address your research question? |
| Authority | Who is the author? What are their credentials? What is the publisher? |
| Accuracy | Is it fact-checked? Does it cite sources? Is it peer-reviewed? |
| Purpose | Why was it written — to inform, argue, sell, or entertain? Does bias affect reliability? |
Key terms
- Thesis Statement
- A specific, arguable claim that a research essay sets out to prove or support
- Primary Source
- An original document, data set, or first-hand account (e.g., a diary, speech, experiment, or work of literature)
- Secondary Source
- A source that analyzes or interprets primary sources (e.g., scholarly articles, textbooks, biographies)
- CRAAP Test
- A source evaluation framework: Currency, Relevance, Authority, Accuracy, Purpose
- Synthesis
- Integrating ideas from multiple sources and connecting them to your own argument
- Plagiarism
- Using another person's words or ideas without proper attribution — a serious academic violation
Flashcards
- Primary Source
- An original document, data set, or first-hand account from the period being studied
- Secondary Source
- A source that analyzes or interprets primary sources
- CRAAP Test
- Source evaluation framework: Currency, Relevance, Authority, Accuracy, Purpose
- Synthesis
- Integrating multiple sources and connecting them to your own argument — beyond mere summary
- Plagiarism
- Using another's words or ideas without proper attribution — an academic integrity violation
- Peer Review
- Expert evaluation of scholarly work before publication — the gold standard for academic credibility
Practice questions
What does the 'A' in the CRAAP test stand for?
- Argument and Analysis
- Authority and Accuracy
- Appropriateness
- Abstract and Attribution
Show answer
Answer: Authority and Accuracy
In the CRAAP test, 'A' actually covers two criteria: Authority (who wrote it and why should we trust them) and Accuracy (is the information correct and well-supported). Some versions list these as two separate letters.
A diary entry written by a Civil War soldier is an example of a primary source.
Show answer
Answer: True
A diary written by someone who directly experienced an event is a primary source — it is an original, first-hand document, not an analysis written later by a historian.
Using another person's words or ideas without proper attribution is called ___.
Show answer
Answer: plagiarism
Plagiarism is academic dishonesty that ranges from copying text without quotation marks to paraphrasing without attribution. It violates intellectual property and undermines the integrity of research.
Synthesis in research writing involves:
- Summarizing only one source at a time
- Bringing multiple sources into conversation and connecting them to your own argument
- Copying quotations without commentary
- Using only primary sources
Show answer
Answer: Bringing multiple sources into conversation and connecting them to your own argument
Synthesis is the highest-level research skill — it requires you to find relationships between sources, identify agreements and disagreements, and weave them into support for your own original argument.
Peer-reviewed scholarly articles are generally considered more credible than random websites because they have been evaluated by experts before publication.
Show answer
Answer: True
Peer review means other credentialed experts in the field have evaluated the research for validity, methodology, and accuracy before publication — a rigorous quality control process absent from most websites.
Fun facts
- Wikipedia is a great starting point for background knowledge and finding primary sources — but most teachers don't accept it as a citable source because it can be edited by anyone.
- The MLA (Modern Language Association) citation format was created in 1951 and is now in its 9th edition — it updates regularly to address new source types like TikTok and podcasts.
- Academic peer review means that before a scholarly article is published, other experts in the field read it anonymously and evaluate its validity — making peer-reviewed sources the gold standard in research.
Get a personalized course on Research Writing and Source Evaluation built around your child.