Comparing Texts
Grade 3 · English · Study Guide
Learn how to look at two texts and find what is the same and what is different.
Reading one book is great. But comparing TWO texts on the same topic or theme can unlock a much deeper understanding. When you compare texts, you are asking: how are these the same? How are they different? This is one of the most powerful thinking skills in all of reading.
When comparing texts, look at the TOPIC (what they are both about), the PURPOSE (why each was written — to inform, entertain, or persuade), the POINT OF VIEW (who is telling the story and what do they think?), and the STRUCTURE (how is the text organized — as a story, as a list of facts, as a poem?). Two texts about wolves, for example, might cover the same animal but from completely different angles — one might be a factual article about wolf behavior, while another is a story told from the wolf's own point of view.
A useful tool for comparing is a VENN DIAGRAM — two overlapping circles. Things that are true about only Text A go in the left circle. Things true about only Text B go in the right circle. Things true about BOTH go in the overlapping middle section. Filling one in organizes your thinking before you write a comparison.
When writing a comparison, use transition words that signal similarity and difference. 'Both texts...' signals similarity. 'However,' 'on the other hand,' and 'unlike' signal difference. 'Similarly,' 'in the same way,' and 'just like' also help the reader follow your comparison. Mastering this skill will serve you in every subject — comparing experiments in science, events in history, or characters in literature.
| Comparison (Same) | Contrast (Different) |
|---|---|
| Both | However |
| Similarly | On the other hand |
| Just like | Unlike |
| In the same way | In contrast |
| Also | But |
Key terms
- compare
- To look at two or more things and identify what is the same
- contrast
- To look at two or more things and identify what is different
- Venn diagram
- A graphic organizer with two overlapping circles used to compare and contrast
- point of view
- The perspective from which a text is written — who is telling it and what they think
Flashcards
- compare
- To find what two things have in common
- contrast
- To find how two things are different
- Venn diagram
- Two overlapping circles used to organize similarities and differences
- transition words — compare
- both, similarly, also, just like, in the same way
- transition words — contrast
- however, unlike, but, on the other hand, in contrast
- point of view
- The perspective from which a text is told
Practice questions
A Venn diagram is used to:
- write a story
- compare and contrast two texts or ideas
- find the main idea
- organize a timeline
Show answer
Answer: compare and contrast two texts or ideas
A Venn diagram's overlapping circles organize similarities and differences.
When comparing texts, you only look at how they are different.
Show answer
Answer: False
Comparing looks at BOTH similarities (compare) and differences (contrast).
The word ___ is a transition word that signals two things are different.
Show answer
Answer: however
'However' signals a contrast or switch — it introduces a difference.
Which transition word shows SIMILARITY between two texts?
- however
- unlike
- but
- similarly
Show answer
Answer: similarly
'Similarly' means 'in the same way' — it connects two similar ideas.
Two texts about the same topic can have different purposes.
Show answer
Answer: True
Two articles about the same animal could have different purposes — one to inform, one to persuade protection efforts.
Fun facts
- Scientists compare texts all the time — it is called 'literature review.' Before running an experiment, scientists read what other scientists found so they can look for similarities and differences.
- The Venn diagram was invented by mathematician John Venn in 1880. He never imagined it would be used in every elementary school classroom in the world!
Get a personalized course on Comparing Texts built around your child.